| 1 | 13:31 | James Madison | Halbert,Miles returns punt, runs 20 yards for a touchdown. | 0–6 |
| 1 | 13:31 | James Madison | Halbert,Miles returns punt, runs 9 yards for a touchdown. | 0–6 |
| 1 | | James Madison | Suarez,Morgan extra point is good. | 0–7 |
| 1 | 09:01 | Wagner | DiSalvatore,Johnny field goal is good. | 3–7 |
| 1 | 07:46 | James Madison | Pettaway,George runs 1 yard for a touchdown. | 3–13 |
| 1 | | James Madison | Suarez,Morgan extra point is good. | 3–14 |
| 1 | 01:16 | James Madison | Pettaway,George runs 1 yard for a touchdown. | 3–20 |
| 1 | | James Madison | Suarez,Morgan extra point is good. | 3–21 |
| 2 | 13:09 | James Madison | Pettaway,George runs 32 yards for a touchdown. | 3–27 |
| 2 | | James Madison | Suarez,Morgan extra point is good. | 3–28 |
| 2 | 07:59 | James Madison | Herman,Nick runs 15 yards for a touchdown. | 3–34 |
| 2 | | James Madison | Suarez,Morgan extra point is good. | 3–35 |
| 2 | 01:00 | James Madison | Scott,Michael returns punt, runs 76 yards for a touchdown. | 3–41 |
| 2 | | James Madison | Suarez,Morgan extra point is good. | 3–42 |
| 3 | 14:20 | James Madison | Herman,Nick runs 77 yards for a touchdown. | 3–48 |
| 3 | | James Madison | Suarez,Morgan extra point is good. | 3–49 |
| 3 | 12:04 | James Madison | Scott,Michael returns punt, runs 69 yards for a touchdown. | 3–55 |
| 3 | | James Madison | Suarez,Morgan extra point is good. | 3–56 |
| 3 | 08:22 | James Madison | Coleman,Camden complete to Collins,Za'Ron. Coleman,Camden runs 18 yards for a touchdown. | 3–62 |
| 3 | | James Madison | Suarez,Morgan extra point is good. | 3–63 |
| 3 | 01:52 | James Madison | Suarez,Morgan field goal is good. | 3–66 |
| 4 | 14:39 | James Madison | Maiden,Arrington complete to Mosley,KD. Maiden,Arrington runs 20 yards for a touchdown. | 3–72 |
| 4 | | James Madison | Suarez,Morgan extra point is good. | 3–73 |
| 4 | 06:48 | James Madison | Maiden,Arrington complete to Halbert,Miles. Maiden,Arrington runs 44 yards for a touchdown. | 3–79 |
| 4 | | James Madison | Suarez,Morgan extra point is good. | 3–80 |
| 4 | 00:22 | James Madison | Donghia,Phoenix runs 1 yard for a touchdown. | 3–86 |
| 4 | | James Madison | Suarez,Morgan extra point is good. | 3–87 |