Safeties: How They Happen and Why They Are Rare
A safety is worth two points and a free kick, yet many fans go entire seasons without seeing one. Here is every way a safety can happen and why the rulebook makes them uncommon.
The scoreboard says 9-7, and for a moment nobody at home can work out how. Three field goals would make nine, and a touchdown with a missed extra point would make six or seven, but the math does not line up until someone points out that the defense scored two points without the ball ever crossing the opposite goal line. The offense, backed against its own goal line, was caught with the ball in its own end zone. That is a safety.
Safeties are the least common way to score in football, and they are also the one most likely to be misunderstood. The word suggests safe, and the play is the opposite of safe for the team on the wrong end of it. This guide covers what a safety is, every way one can be scored, the idea of impetus that decides who is responsible, what happens after a safety and why such plays are rare.
What a safety is
A safety is a score of two points for the defense, awarded when the ball becomes dead in the offense's own end zone and the offense is responsible for the ball being there. The team that gave up the safety must then kick the ball to the team that scored.
Two features set it apart from other scores. The first is that the points are awarded to the team that did not have the ball, usually the defense. The second is that the scoring team receives the ball afterward, through a free kick from the other team. A safety therefore gives a team points and possession, which explains why a safety swings a game by more than the two points on the board.
You can read about how safeties fit with the other scoring plays in how scoring works in football.
The idea that decides everything: impetus
Whether a play in the end zone is a safety or a touchback depends on a rulebook idea called impetus. Impetus is the force that sent the ball into the end zone. The team that supplied the impetus is the team responsible for the ball being there.
- If the offense supplied the force that put the ball in its own end zone, and the ball becomes dead there, the result is a safety.
- If the defense supplied the force that put the ball in the offense's end zone, the result is a touchback, and the offense gets the ball at its 20-yard line (the touchback spot differs by level and situation, which we cover in touchbacks explained).
Here is a hypothetical to make it concrete. Imagine a running back takes the ball at his own two-yard line and is tackled at the one. The ball is in the field of play, so nothing special happens. Now imagine he takes the ball at the two, steps backward and is tackled in the end zone. His own team's action moved him back across the goal line. That is a safety, because the offense supplied the force.
Now imagine a defender intercepts a pass inside his own five-yard line and his own momentum carries him across the goal line, where he is tackled. The ball was first possessed in the field of play, and the offense did not push it into the end zone, so most rulebooks, the NFL's included, rule a touchback rather than a safety. This is often called the momentum exception: the team that was moving the ball in its own direction only loses the points when it is the one that carried the ball backward. Officials sometimes need replay to decide where the ball was first controlled, and the exact wording differs by level.
Every way a safety can happen
Most safeties fit into a short list. Here are the situations in which the offense is charged with the impetus.
- A ball carrier is tackled in his own end zone. A runner, or a quarterback who is sacked, is downed with the ball in his end zone after having carried it there or after taking a snap there. This is the classic safety.
- A fumble or backward pass goes out of bounds through the offense's end zone. The offense fumbled or threw the ball backward, and the force of that carried it into and out of its own end zone. The ball is dead, and the defense is awarded two points.
- A blocked punt goes through the end zone. When a punt is blocked and the ball goes out of bounds in the kicking team's own end zone, or the kicking team recovers it there and is downed, the kicking team supplied the impetus by kicking it, so the result is a safety.
- A penalty by the offense in its own end zone. At the NFL level, certain offensive fouls committed in the offense's own end zone, such as holding, result in a safety. The rule is that when the spot of enforcement would place the ball behind the goal line, the result is a safety. Other levels enforce these penalties differently, and many do not produce a safety in the same way.
- Intentional grounding in the end zone. A passer who commits the foul while in his own end zone gives up two points. See intentional grounding explained.
- A ball carrier steps out of bounds in his own end zone. If a runner crosses the end line or sideline within his own end zone while carrying the ball that the offense put there, the ball is dead and the result is a safety.
Not every defensive play in the end zone is a safety. A defensive touchdown on a fumble recovery or a pick-six is a touchdown. A returner who catches a kickoff in the end zone and is tackled there has not given up a safety either, because the kick, supplied by the other team, put the ball in the end zone.
What happens after a safety
After a safety, the team that gave up the points kicks the ball to the other team. This kick is called a free kick. The kicking team puts the ball in play from its own 20-yard line, and it can use a punt, a drop kick or a place kick. The kick is not a normal kickoff, and the details of what equipment may be used for the kick, such as a tee, vary by level of play.
That has two consequences.
- The team that gave up the safety also gives up possession. It has been scored upon, and it loses the ball.
- The team that scored gets the ball with a likely good field position, because the kick has to travel from the 20, and punts from the 20 typically land well past midfield.
The strategic effect of a safety is therefore larger than two points. Coaches sometimes call it a four-to-seven point swing, because it is the sum of the score and the field position that follows. That phrase is a coach's rule of thumb, not an official statistic.
A worked example of the swing
Imagine a hypothetical game in the fourth quarter. Team A leads 13-12, and it has the ball at its own one-yard line after a good punt by the other side. On first down the quarterback drops back, is hit, spins away and is wrapped up by two defenders in the end zone.
The scoring is simple: Team B gets two points and leads 14-13. The consequences are larger. Team A must now kick from its own 20-yard line, so Team B will get the ball after the free kick, probably near midfield. A team that was ahead and about to run the clock is behind and about to defend. If Team B then drives for a field goal, a one-point lead has become a four-point lead before the original team has touched the ball again.
Analysts like examples of this kind because they show why a safety is judged by more than the two points. Whenever you see one, check the game clock and the score. A safety in the first quarter is a curiosity, but the same play in the final minutes can decide the game.
Why safeties are rare
Safeties happen only a few times in a typical NFL season across the entire league, and some seasons produce a very small number. The reasons are structural.
The offense avoids the end zone
Teams that start a drive near their own goal line change their play calling. They run short, safe plays, and when a run is not working, they punt. A quarterback in the end zone is trained to throw the ball away, take a sack outside the end zone if possible or step up in the pocket. The coaching goal is simply to avoid being tackled in the end zone.
Punt protection
A punter kicking from deep in his own end zone is protected by a unit whose whole job is to stop a block, and a blocked punt that then leaves through the end zone is rare. Most punts, even bad ones, simply go downfield.
Fumbles tend to be recovered
A fumble in the end zone is usually recovered by a player on one of the two teams. If the offense recovers it and is tackled, that is a safety, but if the defense recovers it, that is a touchdown. The offense has an incentive to fall on a loose ball but to avoid being tackled while holding it.
The rules sort close plays into touchbacks
The impetus rules and the momentum exception narrow the safety category to plays the offense itself caused. A defender who carries an intercepted ball back across his own goal line, or a returner tackled after catching a kick in the end zone, produces a touchback instead.
Offensive coaches plan for it
Many safeties come from specific problem situations, such as a quarterback who holds the ball too long in his own end zone or a snap that sails over the punter's head. Coaches practice those plays, and the players who handle snaps are trained to fall on a loose ball. Those habits do not eliminate safeties, but they reduce them.
Because safeties are so rare, a fan who attends several games may never see one. They are most likely to occur in games with strong pass rushes, poor field position or bad weather that makes snaps and kicks difficult.
A quick reference
| Situation | Who gets the points | What happens next |
|---|---|---|
| Runner tackled in his own end zone | Defense gets 2 | Offense kicks a free kick from its own 20 |
| Fumble or backward pass out of bounds through the offense's end zone | Defense gets 2 | Free kick by the offense |
| Blocked punt goes through the kicking team's end zone | Defense gets 2 | Free kick by the kicking team |
| Intentional grounding in the end zone | Defense gets 2 | Free kick by the offense |
| Defender's momentum carries an intercepted ball into his own end zone | No safety; usually a touchback | Ball placed by the touchback rule |
Safeties on tries and at other levels
The details of safeties differ somewhat by level.
- NFL. The two-point safety and the free kick follow the pattern described above. The rules on penalties in the end zone create more safeties at this level than at some others.
- College. The basic rule is the same, with differences in how penalties are enforced in the end zone and in how the free kick is set up.
- High school. High school football follows the National Federation of State High School Associations rulebook, which has its own wording for a safety and the free kick that follows. State associations can modify it.
- Tries after touchdowns. A try is the extra-point or two-point play after a touchdown. Some rulebooks allow a one-point safety to be awarded to the offense in a rare situation on a try, where the defense gains possession and then the ball becomes dead in the defense's own end zone. It is extremely uncommon. Check the book for your level to see if it applies, and read about the tries in extra point rules.
Common misconceptions
A few myths about safeties show up often.
- "A safety is a tackle in the end zone." It is a tackle in the end zone only when the offense is responsible for the ball being there.
- "A safety is worth one point." A standard safety is worth two points at the NFL, college and high school levels.
- "The team that scores a safety gets the ball by kickoff." It gets the ball by free kick from the other team, not a regular kickoff.
- "A safety can only be scored by the defense on a sack." Sacks are one cause. Penalties, fumbles through the end zone, blocked punts and a runner out of bounds can also produce them.
- "A sack in the end zone is a touchback." A sack of a quarterback in his own end zone is a safety.
If you follow games on our scores page or look up a team on the teams pages, a safety appears as a two-point entry in the scoring summary. It is a good habit to check how it happened, because the detail tells you whether the offense made a mistake or the defense made a great play. Our standings page shows how those points affect the season, since every point counts in the points-for and points-against totals used in some tiebreakers.
The short version
- A safety is two points for the defense, awarded when the offense is responsible for the ball becoming dead in its own end zone.
- Impetus decides who is responsible: if the offense put the ball there, it is a safety, and if the defense did, it is a touchback.
- Safeties come from tackles in the end zone, fumbles or backward passes through it, blocked punts that exit it, certain end-zone penalties, intentional grounding and a runner stepping out of bounds there.
- The team that gave up the safety kicks to the other team on a free kick from its own 20-yard line.
- Safeties are rare because teams avoid the situations that produce them, and the rules turn many close plays into touchbacks.
- Penalty enforcement and free-kick details differ by level, so check the rulebook for yours.